my Movie

Movie Details

Title:   Bucking Broadway
Director:   John Ford
Year:   1917
Genre:   Silent
Times Seen:   1
Last Seen:   11.12.26

Other Movies Seen By This Director (5)
- Fort Apache
- The Informer
- She Wore A Yellow Ribbon
- Stagecoach
- Young Mr. Lincoln

Notes History
Date Viewed Venue Note
11.12.26DVDThis Screening is part of event: DVRfest 2026
Day 3 of this year's DVRfest returns to one of our longest-running traditions: the Criterion random roll.

Eagle-eyed readers might remember that last year we started a new phase in the ongoing quest to actually watch all the movies I buy: the box set. I still have my list of ~35 movies pulled from assorted criterion and eclipse box sets that I own (50 if you include Godzilla), and I have added a box set in the ensuing year. Alas, I think there's only 1 Kubrick movie I haven't seen? and I'm iffy on that? In any case, when you read below you might ask yourself "hey, psychotic person who still reads this journal, that isn't from a box set!" Well, you'd be right. In addition to buying that great big fuck-off Kubrick box, I also got a new standalone release that I haven't seen! And also, I realized that a few of the releases for movies I have seen also include OTHER movies that I have not! So today we're back down to the wee digits to catch up on these individual releases, then it's back to box set land where anything's possible.

Ok, logistics settled. Got my soda, got my kettle chips, slept in after last night's Halloween mega tape fun, what's first?

roll: 1
spine: 516

To quote the DVD menu on the second disc for Stagecoach: "this fifty-four-minute silent film from 1917 is one of John Ford's earliest works. A rollicking western about a cowboy (director favorite Harry Carey) whose true love is whisked away by a city slicker, Bucking Broadway showcases the underdog protagonist, jovial humor, regard for family unity, and epic visual style that would become hallmarks of the director."

Glad this came up first. It's been quite a while since I've watch a silent film and I've lost my temperament for it. You really have to put yourself in a mindset. Even though this is a western and (i believe) still probably set 30 years in the past, thinking about what the world was like when this came out held more interest for me than the narrative. It's interesting to think that the desert (I think it was set in Wyoming? But it looked pretty southwest to me) hasn't changed a bit, and human beings for the most part are the same, but this is like 110 years old now. Were crowds fascinated by the moving story of the girl being courted by the cowhand and the city slicker and picking the city slicker so the cowhand comes a runnin' and there's a fight at the end?

I do still think it's neat how they tinted the film for different looks or locales, and Harry Carey's so young as to almost be unrecognizable, but this was a pretty long 50 minutes. Let's move on to something that will undoubtedly hold my interest better.


Oh, also, shout-out to the DVD format. It's my favorite. I know the resolution is tough these days when we have 4K home systems but it makes up the bulk of my collection and it was a (relatively) open format that was easily broken which led to super easy players and software. It was also the moment in my lifetime where a movie fan could really indulge. There was a period where they sold VHS to the home market, some even with a couple special features like a deleted scene or something. I got a copy of Fargo which came with a little snowglobe that was fun. But I think DVDs hit the DC area test market in 96 and "won" the battle over divX in 97 or 98 or something and every studio saw that people were buying and went all-in.

Laserdisc was great but too expensive for me, VHS was my mom's thing (I know I've mentioned it before but she had about... geez I think it got up past 1000 blank tapes that she recorded 2-3 movies each on, with a huge rolodex alphabetized by title with the little summary cut out of a TV guide and taped to the card. She also had a box set of her favorite miniseries (Centennial) and the Godfather whatchamacallit cut where 1 and 2 are cut together chronologically. We had the "first" special edition of the Star Wars original trilogy (where they just did some color grading and a new transfer but before the digital re-releases), and maybe a small stack of other direct-to-market releases but her real collection were those blanks. The sound and image quality was terrible - some were taped off pre-cable antenna stations with static and everything - but when she came down with a cold, she could pick any movie and chances were she'd like the other 2 movies on the same tape so she'd just watch the whole tape.

I followed this trend later once I got my own tv and vcr in my room. While in high school, a few "cool" movies came on cable I wanted to get. I taped Heavy Metal when HBO or somewhere broadcast it and shared with my friends. I bought a bootleg of Akira from my comic book shop. And, um, I kinda sorta had my own version of Paul Rudd's "boner jams" tape from 40-year-old virgin. Friday night I'd turn on cinemax and watch all the softcore stuff and when I thought there might be a hot sex scene I'd hit record. If I didn't like it I'd rewind and try again, so I wound up with a pretty potent montage of stuff that made my teenage brain bristle.

Anyway, so I have love for VHS. After college when I was in my film snob phase and moved back home in a pre-life crisis where I didn't do anything for 3 years, I was the one scouring the TV guide each week, setting the vcr (then the tivo) to record shit at all hours. 7am noirs on TCM? got 'em. the one time a year TCM ran The Green Slime? Got it. Practically everything on the satellite's PPV? Saw em. But by then I was also collecting DVD.

DVD hit when I was back home my first summer in college. The Suncoast Motion Picture Company in the mall had early discs like The Wild Bunch you had to flip but they were like 50 bucks each. It wasn't until I was back at school that it started becoming a thing and somewhere around the beginning of my third year I finally bought a player and my first official purchase: the Elite release of Night of the Living Dead. Along with my friends, we ran a DVD review site so we all dived pretty deep in. I remember buying a porn (Taboo 17) strictly because it had special features. I was very curious to know what a behind the scenes featurette looked like or what a commentary track sounded like (spoiler alert: mostly hilarious, a tiny bit titillating).

So when I moved back home after college I already had a modest collection. But then somewhere in the early 2000s the format just boomed. Sam's Club had a table stacked high with all the releases for like 15 bucks a pop. Every movie I'd ever seen or loved came out in widescreen with special features and, if it was a cool movie, some sort of gimmicky release. My foam latex necronomicon edition of Evil Dead 2 is still right there on the shelf. So that was really when my collection balooned, and by the time I moved here after working for my dad for 18 months the releases were pretty serious. Sin City came out and every studio who'd ever made a film noir put them out, often with commentaries by the same 2 dudes (shout out Alasin Silver and James Ursini). Tarantino and Rodriguez' Grindhouse came out and even though I think it bombed it flooded the marketplace with drive-in and exploitation releases, leading the way to Vinegar Syndrome and Arrow and Blue Underground and everyone else.

It wasn't all bliss. After an amazing and creative start as studios tried to figure out how much time and money to put into these things, they all sort of settled down for the most part to boring commentaries with the actors recorded before the movie comes out and EPK-style BTS vignettes around 4 - 7 minutes each. The 90-minute making-of docs by Laurent Bouzereau started going missing on the Universal releases along with the hidden score-only audio tracks or the exhaustive amount of deleted scenes. Even Criterion, carrying over its legacy of special features from the laserdisc days with early dvd releases like Brazil with all it's various cuts started putting out some stuff with barely any extras.

Then came HD. HD-DVD, the open format vs. Sony again with Blu-Ray. And Blu-Ray won and it became about streaming new ads to your menus and the shit got locked down again. I had to tweak VLC player to get some of these blus to play and since I don't have java installed some menus don't work. I feel like studio new releases became much less of a thing, streaming quickly took over, and now blu-ray (and 4k) fill this collector niche where many films get amazing love and care but it's just not a mainstream medium anymore. It's become vinyl. DVD was the CD.

Whew, where did that come from? Ok let's watch the next movie.